Two ways to move a fly or lure
A fly rod uses the fly line to help deliver the fly. A spinning setup generally casts the weight of the lure or rig. That changes how the cast feels and how you manage the presentation. Neither approach removes the need to read the water.
A streamer gives you line choice, mends, swings, strips and pauses to work with. A spin rod changes the casting and retrieve. We enjoy throwing streamers, but you don’t need to arrive already comfortable with them. Tell us what you fish now and what you want to learn. We can talk through suitable gear and legal options before the trip.
Depth and speed come first
Look at the current, the bank and the water you want to cover. A fly that stays above the intended lane or races through it may need a different depth or speed before it needs another color. Pay attention to when the line comes tight and what happens during a pause.
Try one change at a time. Adjust the casting angle, retrieve, weight or line choice and notice the result. Keep the next few casts comparable. If you change everything after every cast, you lose the chance to learn which adjustment mattered.
Choose a setup you can fish comfortably
A method you can repeat gives you more time to fish. If a heavy fly feels awkward, stop and work through the cast with your guide. Keep the other angler and your own body out of the hook’s path. Talk through casting positions before starting from a boat.
There is no need to make a learning day an endurance test. Tell us if your arm needs a break or if you want to try another presentation. A few comfortable, deliberate casts are more useful than an hour of fighting a setup you don’t enjoy.
Compare the right river, then check the rules
The Missouri River below Holter and the Blackfoot River near Bonner have their own flow records. The links below open those stations. Look at the recent trend as well as the number. Neither reading tells you how fast your fly will move in a particular bank pocket.
Check current FWP regulations, including water-specific tackle restrictions, and the closure notices before choosing either method. Bring any gear questions into the trip conversation. We will work from the water, the rules and the group’s comfort, then spend the day fishing rather than arguing over which rod somebody should like.
River flows for this read
Measured flow in cubic feet per second (CFS). Check the station, timestamp and trend for the stretch you plan to fish.
- Missouri RiverWolf Creek · below Holter Dam · USGS 06066500Check Water Flows here
- Blackfoot RiverBonner · USGS 12340000Check Water Flows here
Field notes
Join the conversation.
Have a question, a field observation, or a correction? Send us a note.